The editor
Hand off
On this page
This page covers moving a cut to and from another app. Clips point at the original files, with their own timecode.
Send a cut out
- On the Deliver page, use Hand off.
- In the File menu, use Export OpenTimelineIO…, Export Final Cut Pro XML…, Export EDL (CMX 3600)… or Export AAF…. On a Mac they’re also in the menu bar, under File › Export Timeline.
Bring a cut in
Use Import a timeline… (Ctrl+Shift+I) in the File menu, or Import Timeline… (Cmd+Shift+I) in the Mac menu bar.
Each clip’s media is found in the pool by its path, then its name. Windows drive and network-share paths are written as file links other apps read, and read back the same way. Media the pool lacks but that exists on disk is imported first, and the timeline is built when that’s done. Clips whose files can’t be found are left out and counted.
Pick a format
| Format | For | Export | Import |
|---|---|---|---|
OpenTimelineIO (.otio) |
A round trip | Every track and clip, plus the editor’s own grade, layer, fades, dissolve, gain and titles | Everything export writes, so a round trip is exact, plus other apps’ OTIO |
Final Cut Pro XML (.fcpxml, 1.10) |
Final Cut Pro or Resolve | Every track as a lane, each file with its own size and rate, picture and sound as one clip, transforms and their keys, crop, speed, opacity, blend modes, titles and their style | Lanes and storylines, transforms, opacity and blend, titles and cross dissolves. Picture and sound of the same frames come back linked |
CMX 3600 EDL (.edl) |
A plain cut list | V1 or a chosen track and its sound, with speed and dissolves | Cuts, sound channels, speed and dissolves |
AAF (.aaf) |
Avid and Pro Tools | Tracks, cuts and dissolves | Tracks, cuts and dissolves |
What each carries
| OTIO | FCPXML | EDL | AAF | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cuts, tracks, sound | Yes | Yes | V1 or one chosen track, plus sound channels | Yes |
| Dissolves | Yes, exactly | Yes, a few frames may move on a file from another app | Yes, as CMX 3600 dissolve events | Yes |
| Start timecode | Yes | Yes | Yes, the first event | Through OTIO |
| Speed, freeze, reverse | Yes | Yes | Yes | Through OTIO |
| Transform, opacity, crop | Yes | Yes, with keys | No | No |
| Titles | Yes | Yes, with style and position | Name only | No |
| Markers | Yes | Yes | No | Partly |
| Grade, masks, effects, compounds, multicam | nolanlabs only | nolanlabs only | No | Through OTIO metadata |
| Reading back our own file | Exact | Exact | The cut | Positions and dissolves |
“nolanlabs only” means a file this editor wrote. It carries the whole clip and track, and nolanlabs reads them back. Another app sees what its format can show.
What won’t travel
- Other apps’ effects are left out on import. OTIO and FCPXML bring the cut, transforms, opacity, speed, titles and dissolves.
- A dissolve leaning to one side can come back a few frames off, because FCPXML doesn’t say where a cut lies inside a dissolve.
- Compound clips and multicam come back when nolanlabs reads the file, but other apps see a plain clip. They don’t become nested sequences in Final Cut.
- Motion clips travel only in OTIO. For another app, write the clip on its own with its alpha. See Titles and motion.
- OTIO image-sequence references aren’t read.
- AAF carries tracks, cuts and dissolves, and needs the Python the app brings.
- EDLs are written non-drop, as the timeline counts its timecode. Drop-frame EDLs and files are read. See Known limits for files at another rate.
- An EDL past 999 events numbers on with four digits, which CMX 3600 doesn’t have. Split a long timeline by track, or use OTIO.
- Media is linked by file, then by a name only one source has. Clips whose files can’t be found are left out, and the editor names them.
For a finished file
To make a file rather than a timeline, see Deliver. To write grades for VFX and dailies, see ASC CDL in Color.